Fit Series • Sizing Guide
By Imam Karakus • Founder, Shoescoo
Short answer: if you have two different size feet, measure both and buy for the bigger foot. A half-size difference is normal and a lace-up shoe plus a thin insole in the smaller shoe usually solves it. At a full size or more, you need split sizes or a shoe built for each foot. Dress shoes for different size feet are harder than sneakers because leather never gets longer, so the length has to be right on both sides.
If one shoe always fits and the other pinches or slips, you probably have two different size feet. It's common, and it's fixable. This guide shows how to measure each foot, what to do at half a size, one size and more, and how to get leather dress shoes that fit both.
ALREADY MEASURED BOTH FEET? START HERE
- Send both feet's numbers: free Fit Check (we answer with a size for each foot)
- A last shaped to your own measurements: custom fit dress shoes (E to 3E)
- One foot also wider than the other: men's wide dress shoes
Is it normal to have two different size feet?
Yes. Many people have one foot a little longer or wider than the other, usually by a few millimetres, sometimes up to half a size. You often only notice it in dress shoes or boots, because firm leather shows a difference that a soft sneaker hides.
A small, lifelong difference is nothing to worry about. If one foot has grown or swollen recently, if the difference came after an injury, or if one foot hurts or goes numb, see a podiatrist before you buy shoes. That is a health question, not a sizing one.
How to measure two different foot sizes at home
Measure both feet, standing, in the evening, in the socks you'll wear with the shoes. For each foot you need three numbers:
- Length: stand on paper with your heel against a wall, mark the tip of your longest toe, and measure wall to mark.
- Width: with your full weight on the foot, hold a pen straight up, mark both sides at the widest part (the ball of the foot), step off and measure straight across between the marks.
- Girth (optional): wrap a soft tape around the ball of the foot. That number is girth, not width. Keep them apart.
Write the numbers down as left and right. The full step-by-step, with the common mistakes, is in our guide on how to measure foot width. To turn your length into a US size, use the men's shoe size guide.
Shoes for different size feet: what to do by difference
Under half a size: fit the bigger foot
Buy the size of your longer foot. Choose a lace-up style (oxford, derby or monk strap with an adjustable strap) so you can pull the smaller shoe tighter. If the smaller foot still moves, add a thin leather insole or a tongue pad to that shoe only.
About one full size: fit the bigger foot and fill the smaller shoe
The bigger foot still decides the size. In the smaller shoe, a full-length insole takes up volume and a heel grip stops the heel from lifting. This works well in lace-ups. In loafers it rarely works, because a loafer has no laces to hold the smaller foot in place.
One and a half sizes or more: split sizes or one shoe per foot
Now padding is not enough. The smaller shoe creases in the wrong place and the toe sits empty. You need a pair with a different size on each side. Some sneaker and comfort brands sell split pairs, and there are odd-shoe exchange programs. For leather dress shoes the honest option is a maker who can build each shoe on its own last.
Easiest to adjust for two foot sizes
Cavalier Derby — Black · $219
A moc-toe derby with an open lacing, so you can pull the smaller shoe tighter. Works with chinos, suits and dark jeans.
Full-grain leather · Blake-stitched leather sole · Standard or Custom fit (E to 3E) · US 7–14 · Made to order in about 3 weeks
See the Cavalier Derby →Not sure about size or width? Send us your foot measurements with the free Fit Check — we'll tell you your size and whether you need Custom fit.
Two different size feet in width, not length
Sometimes the length is the same and only one foot is wider, often because of a bunion on one side. Don't size up for the wider foot. A bigger size adds length, so both heels slip. Fit the length, then get the width the wider foot needs, and let the laces take up the difference on the narrower one. If the wider foot needs E or more, look at men's wide dress shoes instead of a longer size.
Why dress shoes are harder than sneakers
- Leather doesn't get longer. Full-grain leather softens and shapes a little across the width. It never adds length, so a too-short shoe stays too short.
- The crease has to sit at your toe joint. If the smaller foot sits too far back, the shoe creases in the wrong place and wears out faster.
- There's less room for padding. A dress shoe fits closer than a sneaker, so a thick insole lifts your heel out of the back.
A dress lace-up for work and suits
Regal Derby — Black · $219
A cap-toe derby in black leather. The laces open wide, which helps when one foot is wider or higher than the other.
Full-grain leather · Blake-stitched leather sole · Standard or Custom fit (E to 3E) · US 7–13 · Made to order in about 3 weeks
See the Regal Derby →How Shoescoo handles different size feet
Every pair is made to order by my dad, his team and me in our family workshop in Gaziantep, Türkiye, in about three weeks. Here is what we can do:
- Small difference (up to about half a size): a Standard (D) pair in the size of your bigger foot, in a lace-up style. Standard pairs come with a free size exchange.
- Bigger difference, or one foot also wider: custom fit. The workshop builds the last from your measurements; for two different feet that can mean a separate last for each foot. Before you pay, I check with the workshop first and tell you honestly whether we can make it and what it costs.
Custom fit pairs are not returnable, but if they don't fit, we remake them once for free. That's why we ask for both feet's numbers first. Read more on custom fit dress shoes (E to 3E).
Common Questions
Should I buy shoes for my bigger or smaller foot?
Your bigger foot. A shoe that is too short hurts and can't be fixed, while a little extra room in the other shoe can be filled with an insole or a heel grip.
How big a difference between two feet is normal?
A few millimetres up to about half a size is very common. If the difference is new, growing or painful, see a podiatrist.
Can I buy two different shoe sizes in one pair?
Some brands sell split-size pairs, mostly sneakers and comfort shoes. For leather dress shoes, you need a maker who can build each shoe on its own last.
What can I put in a shoe for a smaller foot?
A thin full-length insole, a tongue pad under the laces, or a heel grip. Use them in the smaller shoe only.
Are loafers good for two different size feet?
Usually not if the difference is more than half a size. A loafer has no laces, so the smaller foot slips out at the heel. Lace-ups are easier to adjust.
Can Shoescoo make each shoe a different size?
Send both feet's measurements through the free Fit Check. We check with the workshop first and tell you honestly whether we can build each shoe on its own last, and the price, before you order.
Buying two pairs? A two-pair bundle saves on both. Build your bundle →
Questions? DM us FIT on Instagram @shoescooo.