Style Guide • Color Match
Black or Brown Shoes for a Wedding? The Ultimate Decision Guide
By Imam Karakus • Founder, Shoescoo
It is the most common question we get: "Can I wear brown shoes to a wedding, or must they be black?" The answer used to be simple (always black), but in 2025, the rules have changed. Here is exactly how to solve the black or brown shoes wedding dilemma based on your suit and the venue.
The Short Answer (Cheat Sheet)
- ⚫ Black Shoes: Must be worn with Tuxedos and Black Suits. Best for formal evening wedding shoes color.
- 🟤 Dark Brown Shoes: Perfect for Navy and Charcoal Grey suits. Great for daytime/church weddings.
- 🟠 Tan/Light Brown: Ideal for Light Grey, Blue, or Beige suits. Best for summer, garden, or beach weddings.
When to Wear Black Shoes
When asking about wedding shoe color men often overlook formality. If the invitation says "Black Tie" or the wedding is after 6 PM, Black is the safest and most elegant choice.
A polished Black Oxford (like our Marquis) is the non-negotiable partner for a tuxedo. It signals respect, tradition, and sophistication.
When to Wear Brown Shoes
The black vs brown wedding shoes debate really opens up with Navy and Grey suits. Brown adds warmth and character that black sometimes lacks.
Dark Brown (Espresso/Chocolate)
This is the most versatile shade. It looks incredibly rich paired with a navy blue suit. It’s formal enough for a ceremony but stylish enough for the reception.
Tan / Walnut
Tan shoes are less formal but high in style. They are the perfect match for lighter blue suits or linen fabrics at outdoor summer weddings.
Matching the Belt
One final rule that is never broken: Match your leathers. If you choose brown shoes, your belt must be the same shade of brown. Black shoes require a black belt (or no belt if wearing a tuxedo/suspenders).
Conclusion: Decide Based on the Suit
Don't overthink it. Look at your suit first. If it's black or a tuxedo, go Black. If it's navy or grey, you have the freedom to explore Brown. Whichever you choose, ensure they are polished and comfortable.
